A Los Angeles apartment building at sunset, warm light in every window, a palm silhouetted against the evening sky.

Home·Guides·Rental property rules

Rental property insurance renewal

What to fix and document before the policy comes due

General education, not legal, tax or financial advice. I am not a licensed real estate agent or broker. My California salesperson license is in progress. For a real lease, use a licensed broker and an attorney.
Direct answer

Start a rental property insurance renewal two to three months before the policy is due. Fix the easy flags first, such as branches over the roof, unstrapped water heaters and old supply lines, and put the proof in one file with photos, dates and invoices. Then compare quotes on the same coverage. On a small building, a premium increase is hard to make up through rent alone.

Why rent rarely covers it

In the example below, the premium on a fourplex rises $2,000 a year, about $42 a unit a month. Rent on many Los Angeles units can only rise by a capped amount in any 12 months, and a larger increase can cost you a good tenant. The Los Angeles rent control guide covers the caps. So work the renewal first.

The easy flags

  • Tree branches over or touching the roof
  • Roof condition, gutters and downspouts
  • Water heaters: California requires residential water heaters of up to 120 gallons to be braced, anchored or strapped to resist earthquake motion, at least to the California Plumbing Code standard (Health and Safety Code 19211)
  • Supply lines and shutoff valves under sinks and toilets
  • Smoke and carbon monoxide alarms
  • The age of the roof, the electrical panel and the plumbing, which applications often ask for

Build the file

Keep one folder per building: dated photos after each fix, invoices, the year of each major system, and the claims history. Give the same file to whoever shops the policy, so every quote is priced on the same facts.

Compare quotes on the same terms

  • The amount of coverage on the building, and whether it pays replacement cost
  • The deductible
  • Loss of rents coverage
  • Liability limits
  • Exclusions, and any limits on water damage

Take the same file to at least three independent carriers, or to an independent agent who can quote several. A cheaper quote with a higher deductible or no loss of rents coverage may not be cheaper after a claim.

Worked example: the renewal gap on a fourplex

Made up numbers.

ItemAmountMath
Current premium$4,000 a year
Renewal quote$6,000 a year
Increase$2,000 a year$6,000 minus $4,000
Per unit per monthAbout $42$2,000 / 4 / 12

Covering $42 a unit a month through rent means an increase every tenant notices, on units where the increase may be capped. Fixing and documenting the easy flags comes first.

The short version

Rental property insurance renewal: what to do first

Read the transcript

If your rental insurance jumped, raising rent will not fix it.

Across Los Angeles, smart owners solve renewals before paying.

Say your annual policy jumps two thousand dollars on a fourplex.

Proactive owners inspect hazards instead of eating the jump.

Take three steps to lower costs.

First, trim tree branches clear of the roofline.

Second, photograph updated plumbing and water heater straps.

Third, take that maintenance file to three independent carriers.

My rule: carriers price physical risk, so remove easy flags.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

When should I start working on an insurance renewal?

Two to three months before it is due, so there is time to fix the easy items and collect quotes.

What should go in the renewal file?

Dated photos after each fix, invoices, the year of each major system, and the claims history, so every quote is priced on the same facts.

Can I raise rent to cover an insurance increase?

Only within the limits that apply to the unit. Many Los Angeles units have a cap on increases over any 12 months, so check the rent limits first.

What is loss of rents coverage?

Coverage that replaces rent while a unit cannot be lived in after a covered loss, such as a fire. Check whether each quote includes it.

Keep reading

More on rental property rules

Property management runs through Topanga Property Management, where I work on business development and marketing systems. Questions about a building go to their team.